Hearties Rank Jane Austen Romantic Leads

Friday 9 June 2017

On the Books With Heart Facebook & Twitter pages, we conducted polls to see who was your favourite Jane Austen romantic lead. Heartie Sarah is here to dissect your results and get into a bother over sideburns!

1. Mr. Darcy (Pride & Prejudice)

source: giphy

Well...that was predictable. Come on, Fitzwilliam Darcy could win this competition until the end of time. When alien's invade earth and we need to describe the perfect fictional romantic hero to them we will just hand over a copy of Pride & Prejudice and say 'you're welcome'.

Favourite portrayal: This could require another poll in itself but I'm sure the hearties would smite me down if I did not choose Colin Firth. Darcy is Firth, Firth is Darcy. 

2. Captain Wentworth (Persuasion)

source: idlesuperstar.tumblr.com

Ladies love a man in uniform apparently! Cap also stands out among this list because he is not of the gentry but rather a self-made man (shock horror)! This didn't stop Anne from pining over him for years and with his high-quality love letters who could blame her? Shout out to the hearties on Twitter who started the #VoteForWentworth campaign!

Favourite portrayal: Ciaran Hinds, hands down! I apologise for ever including Rupert Penry-Jones in the Facebook poll. Those cheek bones, that romantic longing in his dark eyes. I'm here for it.

3. Mr. Knightley (Emma)

source: badlydoneemma.blogspot

Sure he's a bit judgemental but hey, some of us need that voice of reason when we're matchmaking the wrong people and tearing down our friends. I've never been the biggest fan of Knightley but he is a great counterpoint to Emma. Despite her flaws, he loves her no matter what, and isn't that all we want in a man?

Favourite portrayal: Paul Rudd in Clueless. I will fight everyone on this point. 

source: giphy

4. Colonel Brandon (Sense and Sensibility)

source: rebloggy

Another man in uniform! We're seeing a trend here hearties. I received so much backlash for not including poor, old Brandon in the original Facebook poll. I was Marianne and you hearties were Elinor convincing me of Brandon's many qualities! He can rescue me from a rainstorm any day of the week.

Favourite portrayal: Alan Rickman. Duh. The voice alone! How could anyone pick Willoughby over him?

5. Edward Ferrars (Sense and Sensibility)

source: naomiblog15.blogspot

A controversial choice! He's not the most interesting character of the bunch and poor sod has to go around wearing a lock of a girl's hair in a ring out of duty. Elinor likes him well enough though and that's good enough for us. 

Favourite portrayal: Dan Stevens. Not even sorry about it, Hugh Grant. Only Dan could make this wet blanket of a character interesting and charming. Have included angsty rain GIF for good measure.

source: tonal-gleeson.tumblr

6. Henry Tilney (Northanger Abbey)

source: giphy

...who? Come now, that's not completely fair. It's not Henry's fault that everyone forgets about Northanger Abbey, published posthumously. He received a measly one vote in our Facebook poll! I wonder if it is because his sarcasm comes across as rather mean to Catherine? Or is it because he's a little bit full of himself? 

Favourite portrayal: JJ Feild is the only portrayal I have seen and he does a great job of bringing this sarcastic charmer to life. He brings a Jude Law-like quality to Henry which suits me just fine. 

7. Edmund Bertram (Mansfield Park)

source: bustle

Wah, wah. Am I the only one who doesn't understand what Fanny sees in Edmund Bertram (besides the fact he is her first cousin)? Apparently not, since he too received only one vote in our Facebook poll. He is the most ignorant man on this list and lets Fanny pine away as he prances about with Mary Crawford *shudder*. Boy bye.

Favourite portrayal: Jonny Lee Miller...we guess??

Honourable Mention

Mr Bingley (Pride & Prejudice)

source: giphy

On our Facebook poll, one heartie pointed out that I didn't include Mr. Bingley. To be honest, I just forgot about him. He's a bit forgettable really... Did anyone really notice Bingley except for Jane and her mother? He is perfectly amiable though and deserves a mention. But he is a spineless jellyfish who let his best friend and sisters drag him away from the woman he loves.

Favourite portrayal: Crispin Bonham-Carter, of course. Who could resist that mop of curls and blue eyes that stare at you long enough without blinking to be almost creepy.

source: victorianachronists.wordpress

Keep an eye on the Books With Heart Facebook & Twitter pages for future Jane Austen polls!

Latest news

Q&A with Penny Sunday

Meet Aussie dark romance author Penny Sunday!

Read an extract from The Wretched Divine

From the bestselling author of Belladonna

Ashleigh Barton's Letter to Readers

Ahead of Eighty-Nine Questions for After, Ashleigh shares her thoughts on why sad books are so important for kids.

Read an extract of True Crime

Start reading Patricia Cornwell's thrilling memoir

The Richell Prize Opens 2026

Announcing this year's round of The Richell Prize

Mum's Shelf, Sorted

Happy Mother's Day!

Read an extract from The Chateau on Sunset

Read the new book from bestselling author Natasha Lester

Read an extract from Rat Daniels

Dive into this unforgettable coming-of-age story from a stunning new voice in Australian fiction

Book Club Questions for Margaret, Are You Leaving?

We hope these questions help guide your book club discussion for this heartfelt novel. We’ve done our best to avoid spoilers, but don’t read these questions unless you’ve finished Margaret, Are You Leaving? – you don’t want to risk ruining any reveals!

Welcome to the World of Donovan Bixley

Entertain the kids at home

Read an Extract from Rebirth: A Love Story From the Depths of War

Antoun Issa powerfully captures his mother's true experiences of love, heartbreak and new hope during the violence of civil war.

Celebrating our CBCA 2026 Notables

The Children's Book Council of Australia's 2026 Notables list has been announced!

Meet J.P. Pomare and Candice Fox on tour across NSW

J.P. Pomare and Candice Fox are teaming up for a scintillating series of events across regional NSW. Hear J.P. discuss his highly charged thriller The Gambler and Candice discuss her addictive new novel Redbelly Crossing.

Natasha Lester On Tour | 2026

Meet bestselling author Natasha Lester as she tours Australia

Book Club Questions for The Gambler

We hope these questions help guide your book club discussion for this incredible thriller. We’ve done our best to avoid spoilers, but don’t read these questions unless you’ve finished The Gambler – you don’t want to run the risk of ruining any reveals!

J.P. Pomare Book Tour 2026

J.P. Pomare will tour Australia to discuss his highly charged new crime thriller, The Gambler, marking the start of an electrifying new series featuring PI Vince Reid.

Supporting our Adelaide Writers Week authors

A guide to our authors

Read an extract from Good People by Patmeena Sabit

A kaleidoscopic, urgent narrative, told through the chorus of voices surrounding the Sharafs, Good People is a riveting, provocative and unforgettable story of community, family and identity.

Read an extract from Finding Her Edge

A swoony YA sports romance coming soon to Netflix

Read an extract from The Swan's Daughter

Stardust meets Uprooted with a fairytale twist in this standalone fantasy.

Read an extract from The Weaver Bride

An unputdownable romantasy steeped in a lush magical world.

Read an extract from Hazelthorn

Knives Out meets Belladonna in this gorgeously gothic queer YA horror and dark romance.

Read an extract from I'll Find You Where the Timeline Ends

A cosy YA timeslip romance with a gorgeous Korean setting

Helping Your Kids Off Screens and into Books

Australia's social media ban is a great opportunity to find fun new activities to share!

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.